Sunday, 28 September 2025

Margaret Hill - a mystery solved...

 

Sometime in 1834, 20 year old Julia Fox commenced employment as a house maid for Miss Frances Harley, in her home in the village of Cowley, near Uxbridge, Middlesex in England.  Miss Harley was a single lady of independent means, the sister of the then Earl of Oxford, so this would have been quite a prestigious household.

Also in the Harley household at that time was young footman Thomas Whitley.  Julia apparently caught Thomas’s eye, and the pair formed a relationship. Julia claimed Thomas had pursued her and made promises of marriage, but when she realised she was pregnant in mid-1835, those promises disappeared and Thomas told her he could do nothing for her and she would need to take care of herself.

With her employer unaware of her predicament, Julia left her position and went to stay nearby with her brother until she could find other employment.  Her brother is not named but worked as a painter for a Coach Maker and had lodgings in nearby Uxbridge.

After a couple of months there, Julia found a position with a family named Todd, residing at 21 Somerset Street, Portman Square. This did not last long, as the family moved away.  By now at an advanced stage of her pregnancy, Julia took lodgings with a Mrs Bright of 13 Queen Street, Grosvenor Square, where her baby girl was born on 13 December 1835. The birth was attended by a neighbour, Mrs Burton from number 3 Queen Street.

With her baby only a month or so old, Julia had to find a means of support. She was recommended for a position as wet nurse, and left her own little girl in the care of Mrs Pearson at 178 Oxford Street while she went to feed another woman’s baby.  John Fearon, a solicitor, and his wife Jessy had recently become parents to a baby girl also named Jessy. They lived at 42 Chester Terrace Regents Park. Whether Mrs Fearon was unable to feed her own baby, or whether she followed the custom of women of her class and chose not to do so, is not known. However, she reported being very pleased with Julia and found her to be of good character.

By April of 1836, Julia had to consider further options to provide for her child. She made application to the London Foundling Hospital to have her little girl accepted for care there.

Early picture of Foundling Hospital 1754
http://catalogue.wellcomelibrary.org/record=b1194805



The London Foundling Hospital first opened its doors to accept destitute children in 1741. The rules governing acceptance into the hospital changed in various ways over the years. By the time Julia was applying for her baby, the rules were that the child should be no more than 12 months old, the mother must be single, and the father unable to be held accountable.

Julia’s application was supported by character references and details of her situation, and after attempts to contact Thomas were unsuccessful, and correspondence to Miss Harley went unanswered, baby number 19891 was accepted into the Institution on 30 April 1836. We don’t know what name Julia had given her baby girl, but the following day she was baptised and became Margaret Hill.

The Foundling Hospital - Coram Story : Coram Story

Records held by the Foundling Hospital show that Margaret was “sent to the country”, a common arrangement for fostering. This would have been for about 5 years, before she returned to London where she was educated, learning to read and write. On 14 May 1850 Margaret made her Confirmation. Then at 15 years of age, she was apprenticed to Alfred Bowden, a surgeon, residing at 5 St Marks Terrace, Brompton, Kensington, to be instructed in household duties.

After 3 years, Margaret moved on from there to the household of Robert Henry Hill, of 2 Lloyd Square, Pentonville, to continue instruction in household duties. Margaret spent 2 years in this position, before leaving London for Southampton on 3 March 1856, where she sailed on 9 March on board the ship “Alfred the Great” for Geelong, Victoria.  Arriving in Geelong on 4 June, Margaret gained employment as a housemaid with a Mr. Anderson of Darneville, for an initial period of 3 months at a wage of 25 shillings.

We don’t know if this employment was extended beyond the initial 3 months, or if Margaret found other employment, but somewhere along the way she met my great grandfather James Dewar and they married on 23 June 1859 in Geelong.  

On her marriage certificate, Margaret named her parents as John Hill, a carpenter, and Mary Chipping. It is clear from the Foundling Hospital records that this is not true, and these names were part of her “new identity”. I wonder if Margaret herself knew this was not true?

What happened to Julia Fox after giving up her baby is as yet unknown, although I am currently exploring her story. She does not appear as Julia Fox in the 1841 England Census. It is possible that she married in the intervening years, making her harder to find.

As for Thomas Whitley, the 1841 Census shows him still in service with Miss Harley at her London town house in Harley Street.  Miss Harley passed away in December 1848, so presumably her household was broken up after that.

Checking my DNA matches for the surnames Fox and Whitley, I found one shared match that traces back to a Julia Fox, but I need to explore that further.  For Thomas, I found 23 shared matches that trace back to a William Whitley and Hannah Parry, of Christleton, Cheshire.  The couple had eight children, the eldest being Thomas, born 1815. I think I’ve found my man!

Interestingly, William Whitley was convicted of larceny in 1833 and sentenced to 14 years transportation to New South Wales.  His wife Hannah and six youngest children followed him out in 1836.  So not only have I found my 2x and 3x great grandparents, but I can also now claim a convict ancestor!

The lives of Julia, Thomas, and William & Hannah will be stories for another day.

https://archives.coram.org.uk